Comparison of AD1 and Ed Military Tubes in Power Amplifiers (Wehrmacht)

Military electronics during World War II were at the forefront of technology, and the German Wehrmacht was one of the leaders in the application of tube technology. Among these, the AD1 tube stands out, along with its rare alternative – the Ed tube, which was also found in military equipment. As vacuum tubes still hold a special place among audio enthusiasts and hi-fi amplifier fans, this article compares these two tubes, evaluating their price, specifications, historical significance, sound characteristics, and providing a summary from both military equipment and modern audio enthusiast perspectives.

---

1. Tube Price

The price of a tube is closely tied to whether it was manufactured for military purposes (indicated by the Wehrmacht stamp with an eagle and swastika on the tube). Listener experience suggests that Wehrmacht-stamped tubes sound better, likely due to the rigorous selection process—only the best-performing examples were chosen for the army and marked accordingly.

• AD1 – Original AD1 tubes made by Telefunken or Valvo are extremely expensive on the collectors' market today. They were also used in Wehrmacht equipment. Due to high demand and limited supply, they are often regarded as the "Holy Grail" of audio tubes. Prices can reach €1000–€2000, thanks to their historical value and legendary quality.

• Ed – The Ed tube was possibly used as a military alternative or experimental version of the AD1. It is rare and therefore more expensive – approximately €1250–€2500 depending on condition and manufacturer.

---

2. Specification Comparison

Key Differences:

The Ed tube can operate at higher voltages and power levels, which would be useful in military equipment requiring greater output strength. This also benefits amplifiers with higher power demands and less sensitive speakers.

The AD1 offers lower capacitance (cg/a), ensuring better high-frequency transmission—important both in military communication systems and in modern high-fidelity audio. Lower capacitance is vital for high-frequency signal quality, especially in sensitive audio systems.

---

3. Historical Significance

The AD1 was developed in the 1930s in Germany (Telefunken) and soon became a benchmark for European audio power triodes. It was widely used in high-quality radio receivers and audio amplifiers. Original tubes today are not just audio components but collectible artifacts. The AD1 was also one of the most important German military triodes, extensively used in Wehrmacht transmitters and communication devices. Its construction and reliability made it a top-tier component in Nazi Germany’s military technology. Today, it holds historical significance both in military history and among audio collectors.

The Ed tube is less well-known and likely served as a later or alternative version of the AD1. It doesn't have the same cultural and historical legacy as the AD1, but it remains a respected choice among vintage audio circles. The Ed tube was also used in military equipment as an alternative or experimental solution. Although its historical documentation is limited, its presence in collections indicates its practical use in military contexts.

---

4. Sound Comparison

The sound of the AD1 is often described as highly musical and warm, with an excellent midrange, wide soundstage, and high detail. Its precise high-frequency response and low internal capacitance make it ideal for high-end SET (Single-Ended Triode) amplifiers.

The Ed tube provides stable and balanced sound, with slightly less high-frequency resolution, possibly due to its higher interelectrode capacitance. However, it can deliver greater power and dynamics, which is an advantage when using less sensitive speakers or listening to modern, energetic music that requires a faster response from the tube.

---

5. Summary

Conclusion:

The Wehrmacht-era AD1 tube remains a technological and historical icon – ideal not only for restoring vintage devices but also for high-end audio applications. The Ed tube, although not as famous, offers a practical and powerful alternative, especially when higher power and dynamics are needed. Both options are historically and technologically significant, each representing German engineering excellence in their own way.

The Powerful and Dynamic Г-811

The Г-811 tube is a high-power stationary electronic component widely used in various radio and audio amplifiers, including military and industrial devices. These tubes have unique characteristics that make them suitable for specific applications, especially compared to 300B and other tubes.

Main Differences in Amplifiers Using Г-811 Tubes

1. Output Power
   The Г-811 is a high-power tube capable of delivering significantly more output power than the 300B. Typical Г-811 amplifiers provide 20-50W per channel (in a push-pull configuration), much more than the usual 7-10W of 300B tubes. This makes the Г-811 ideal for high-power, high-efficiency speakers or large spaces requiring greater volume.

2. Application and Design
   Г-811 tubes are gas-discharge tubes with a steel body, commonly used in push-pull (differential) amplifiers. Unlike the 300B, which is often employed in single-ended (SE) designs, the Г-811 works well in push-pull configurations, maximizing power efficiency and stability.

3. Construction and Size
   The Г-811 is larger and heavier than the 300B. Its cross-sectional design makes it suitable for heavy-duty equipment such as professional audio amplifiers and radio stations. Amplifiers using Г-811 tubes tend to be larger, incorporating more massive transformers and complex cooling systems.

4. Sound Characteristics
   Г-811 tubes are known for their powerful and dynamic sound, making them ideal for large spaces and music genres that demand more power and dynamics, such as rock, metal, pop, and live recordings. While the 300B is valued for its warmth and musical nuance, the Г-811 offers more energy, power, and dynamics, making it suitable for modern music playback. When used in a single-ended design, it can achieve a similar level of sound depth and detail as 300B, ED(43), and 4П1Л tubes.

5. Usage Scope and Demand
   Г-811 tubes are mainly used in high-power audio amplifiers and professional sound systems, such as concert equipment and stationary audio amplifiers. Unlike 300B tubes, which are popular among audiophiles for high-fidelity home audio, the Г-811 is more oriented toward the professional market.

6. Cost and Availability
   Г-811 tubes are generally more affordable than 300B tubes but can be harder to find for individual users. They are more commonly found in military and professional equipment rather than commercial audiophile products. However, when used in commercial audio systems, they provide higher power and efficiency.

7. Durability and Maintenance
   With their high-power capabilities and steel-body construction, Г-811 tubes are typically more durable than 300B tubes, making them better suited for intensive use. However, like all tubes, they require periodic maintenance and replacement due to their high operational stress.

8. Energy Consumption
   Due to their high power output, Г-811 tubes consume more energy than 300B tubes, leading to higher heat dissipation and the need for efficient cooling systems.

Differences Between Push-Pull and Single-Ended Г-811 Amplifiers

Г-811 tubes can be used in both push-pull (differential) and single-ended circuits, but their performance and advantages vary significantly depending on the design.

1. Push-Pull Configuration (Г-811)

Push-pull circuits are common in tube amplifiers, using two tubes per channel operating in opposite phases—one "pushes," while the other "pulls" the signal, creating a symmetrical operation.

Key Features and Benefits:

• High Power: A push-pull configuration fully utilizes the Г-811’s potential, delivering around 50W per tube. This results in greater loudness and better low-frequency control.
• Lower Distortion: The push-pull design reduces third-harmonic distortion and signal asymmetry, providing a cleaner and more precise sound.
• Higher Efficiency: This design uses power more efficiently, offering greater output with lower energy consumption and heat dissipation.
• Larger Speaker Requirements: Push-pull amplifiers with Г-811 tubes are often designed for high-power speakers and larger spaces.

Best Suited For:

• Large rooms, high-power sound systems, professional audio equipment, and concert setups requiring high sound levels and precision.

2. Single-Ended Configuration (e.g., Shishido Circuit)

Single-ended (SE) circuits use a single tube per channel to amplify the signal. Unlike push-pull designs, SE amplifiers do not operate symmetrically.

VS-Audio tube amplifier G-811

Key Features and Benefits:

• Warm and Musical Sound: SE circuits, especially with tubes like the 300B or Г-811, produce a warmer, more organic sound with rich harmonics. This design amplifies signals in a simple, direct way, creating a more natural listening experience.
• Natural Harmonics: SE circuits have more pronounced third-harmonic distortion, adding a perceived "warmth" and "softness" to the sound. This is one reason why audiophiles favor SE designs for their musicality.
• Lower Power Output: SE configurations with Г-811 tubes deliver lower power than push-pull designs, making them better suited for high-efficiency speakers in smaller spaces.
• Simplicity and Lower Noise: SE circuits are relatively simple, with fewer components, reducing signal loss and unwanted noise.

Best Suited For:

• Home audio enthusiasts looking for warm, detailed, and natural sound reproduction without requiring high volume.

3. Comparison of Push-Pull vs. Single-Ended Г-811 Amplifiers

Aspect	Push-Pull (Г-811)	Single-Ended (Shishido, Г-811)
Power Output	High (20-50W per channel)	Low (less than 10W per channel)
Distortion	Lower, minimal third-harmonic distortion	Higher, with pronounced third-harmonic distortion
Sound Character	Clean, precise, powerful	Warm, soft, and musical
Efficiency	Higher efficiency, greater power	Lower efficiency, simpler design
Recommended Use	Large spaces, high-power speakers, professional setups	Home use, high-efficiency speakers, smaller rooms
Complexity	More complex, heavier construction	Simpler, with fewer components

Summary

• Push-Pull Г-811 Amplifiers: Ideal for high-power applications, large rooms, and professional audio setups where precision and power are required. They offer higher efficiency, lower distortion, and greater volume.
• Single-Ended Г-811 Amplifiers: Preferred by audiophiles seeking warm, detailed, and musical sound. Best suited for smaller rooms, home audio systems, and listeners who prioritize musicality over volume.

Whether used in push-pull or single-ended circuits, the Г-811 tube remains a powerful and versatile choice for various high-end and professional audio applications.

The Valvo ED43 Tube: A Historical Overview

Introduction

The Valvo ED43 tube is a significant achievement in vacuum tube technology, holding an important place in the development of mid-20th-century electronics. It was designed for military applications, specifically for the Wehrmacht’s communication and signaling systems during World War II. The ED43 tube was engineered to withstand the harsh conditions of warfare and ensure reliable operation in radio communications, encryption devices, and other strategically essential equipment.

Design and Features

The ED43 is a medium-power rectifier tube, distinguished by its durable glass envelope and bayonet-style base. This construction allowed it to function in various military devices, providing stable conversion of alternating current (AC) into direct current (DC).

One of the key characteristics of the ED43 was its ability to operate at high voltage levels, a crucial requirement for devices used in wartime conditions. Thanks to this feature, the tube was widely implemented in:

• Field radio stations – ensuring reliable communication between different military units, which was vital for coordinating operations.
• Encryption devices – securing information and enabling safe military communications.
• Radio signal reception and transmission equipment – allowing for precise and efficient wartime information exchange.

Valvo ED43 tube in VS-Audio amplifier

Historical Context

The Valvo ED43 was developed during a period of rapid advancements in electronics. As the war intensified, the demand for reliable communication systems grew. The Wehrmacht, the armed forces of Nazi Germany, heavily relied on effective communication to coordinate its operations. The introduction of the ED43 tube reflected these needs, merging innovation with practicality.

Original Valvo ED43 with Wehrmacht sign from VS-Audio amplifier

Moreover, the production of the ED43 was part of a broader effort to supply high-quality electronic components that met the demands of warfare. Valvo, a company renowned for its expertise in vacuum tube technology, played a crucial role in manufacturing these components, ensuring that the electronic systems they powered could endure the challenges of modern warfare.

Valvo Factory

Valvo was a German company specializing in the production of vacuum tubes and electronic components. Founded in 1924 in Hamburg, Valvo initially focused on radio and lighting technologies but later became one of Europe’s leading vacuum tube manufacturers. During World War II, the factory supplied high-quality tubes, including the ED43, for the Wehrmacht’s communication and electronic systems.

After the war, Valvo continued to develop and became part of the Philips group, expanding into semiconductors and modern electronic components. The brand remained well-known until the late 20th century, and its tubes are still highly sought after by vintage audio and radio enthusiasts.

Legacy and Modern Implications

Although the ED43 was originally designed for military use, it has not lost its value in modern times. Vintage audio and radio enthusiasts appreciate this tube for its unique sonic characteristics and the historical authenticity it brings to restored equipment—qualities that modern components often fail to replicate.

The ED43 remains sought after and used in:

• High-power tube amplifiers – delivering warm, rich, and detailed sound, highly valued in premium audio setups.
• Retro communication devices – restorers and collectors use the ED43 to revive authentic World War II-era radios and amplifiers.
• Tube audio enthusiast circles – in the audiophile world, vacuum tubes are often credited with producing a more “organic” and “lively” sound compared to transistors, making the ED43 a prized component in high-end sound systems.

Tube amplifier Ed43 from VS-Audio

The engineering principles behind the ED43 continue to influence modern tube technology and electronics. Engineers and enthusiasts frequently look back at such designs as benchmarks of reliability and performance, contributing to a deeper understanding of the evolution of electronics over the decades.

Tube amplifier Tower-Ed from VS-Audio

Conclusion

The Valvo ED43 tube is not only a technological innovation but also a historical artifact, demonstrating how military needs have driven advancements in electronics. From World War II military equipment to modern vintage audio applications, the ED43 continues to thrive among enthusiasts and collectors.

This tube’s legacy serves as a reminder of the close connection between technology and history, illustrating how past engineering solutions can still find relevance and application in today's world.

Solid State vs. Tube Amplifiers: Pros and Cons You Should Know

When it comes to amplifiers, the debate between solid-state and tube amplifiers has been ongoing for decades. Each type has its own set of advantages and drawbacks, making them suitable for different users and applications. Whether you are an audiophile, musician, or sound engineer, understanding these differences can help you make an informed decision.

Tube Amplifiers: Pros and Cons

Tube amplifiers, also known as valve amplifiers, use vacuum tubes to amplify signals. They are renowned for their warm, rich, and dynamic sound, making them a popular choice among guitarists and audiophiles.

Tube amplifier from VS-Audio

Pros:

1. Warm and Natural Sound – Tube amplifiers produce a smooth, warm tone that many musicians and audio enthusiasts prefer.

2. Harmonic Distortion – The natural distortion from tube amps is often described as pleasant and musical, enhancing the listening experience.

3. Dynamic Response – Tube amps respond well to touch and playing dynamics, providing a more expressive and organic sound.

4. Classic Aesthetic and Feel – Many musicians appreciate the vintage look and feel of tube amps.

Cons:

1. Fragility and Maintenance – Vacuum tubes are delicate and can burn out over time, requiring periodic replacement and maintenance.

2. Heat Generation – Tube amps generate significant heat, which can be a drawback in certain environments.

3. Size and Weight – They are generally bulkier and heavier compared to solid-state amplifiers.

4. Higher Cost – Tube amplifiers tend to be more expensive upfront and in terms of maintenance.

Solid-State Amplifiers: Pros and Cons

Solid-state amplifiers use transistors instead of vacuum tubes, making them more durable and reliable for many applications, particularly in live performances and professional audio setups.

Pros:

1. Durability and Reliability – Solid-state amps are more robust, less prone to damage, and do not require tube replacement.

2. Lighter and More Portable – They are generally more compact and easier to transport than tube amplifiers.

3. Energy Efficient – They generate less heat and consume less power compared to tube amps.

4. Affordable – Solid-state amplifiers are often more budget-friendly, both in initial cost and long-term maintenance.

Cons:

1. Sound Quality – While some solid-state amps can mimic the warmth of tube amplifiers, many still lack the natural harmonic distortion that gives tube amps their characteristic sound.

2. Less Responsive to Dynamics – Solid-state amps do not react as organically to playing dynamics, which can make them sound less expressive.

3. Harsh or Sterile Tone – Some users find that solid-state amps produce a less pleasing and more clinical sound.

Speaker Considerations for Tube and Solid-State Amplifiers

The choice of speakers can significantly impact the performance of both tube and solid-state amplifiers. Different speakers complement each amplifier type in unique ways.

Speakers for Tube Amplifiers:

1. High-Efficiency Speakers – Tube amplifiers often have lower wattage, so they pair best with high-efficiency speakers to maximize volume and dynamics.

2. Warm-Toned Speakers – Since tube amps emphasize warmth, using speakers with a balanced or slightly bright character can prevent excessive coloration.

3. Impedance Matching – Tube amps are sensitive to speaker impedance, so using speakers that match the amp’s recommended impedance ensures optimal performance.

Speakers for Solid-State Amplifiers:

1. Wide Power Handling Range – Solid-state amps can deliver higher wattages, so speakers with a robust power rating ensure durability and prevent distortion.

2. Flat Response Speakers – Since solid-state amps tend to have a more neutral sound, using flat response speakers ensures accurate audio reproduction.

3. Lower Sensitivity Options – Because solid-state amps can provide more power, they can drive lower-sensitivity speakers effectively without sacrificing volume.

Which One Should You Choose?

The choice between a tube amplifier and a solid-state amplifier depends on your personal preferences, needs, and budget. If you prioritize warm, dynamic sound and don’t mind maintenance, a tube amplifier might be the right choice. However, if you need something durable, portable, and budget-friendly, a solid-state amplifier is likely the better option.

Ultimately, the best way to decide is by testing both types and determining which sound and feel suit your style best. Whether you are a musician seeking the perfect tone or an audiophile chasing pristine sound quality, understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each amplifier type will help you make the best choice for your setup.

Loftin-White Circuit

The Loftin-White circuit is a special type of Single-Ended (SE) Class A tube amplifier design, developed by engineers Loftin and White in the early 20th century. It is known for its direct coupling between amplifier stages, eliminating the need for interstage capacitors, which are traditionally used for signal transmission between stages.

How Does It Work?

Direct Coupling:

• In conventional tube amplifiers, signal transmission between stages is typically achieved using capacitors or transformers.
• In the Loftin-White circuit, the preamp tube is directly connected to the grid of the power tube, utilizing a proper voltage offset.

Stable and Pure Signal:

• Eliminates phase shifts and frequency distortions that capacitors might introduce.
• Provides a clean, detailed, and naturally musical sound with minimal modifications to the original signal.

Simpler but More Precise Circuit:

• Reduces the number of components in the signal path, helping to minimize interference and noise.
• However, precise component selection and careful construction are crucial for proper operation.

Why is the Loftin-White Circuit Special?

✔ Cleaner and more natural sound – fewer signal alterations between tubes.
✔ Fewer components – simpler design but requires greater precision.
✔ Minimal phase shifts and interference – more stable and transparent sound.

This circuit is particularly popular among audiophiles seeking maximum sound purity and musical expression. It pairs exceptionally well with high-sensitivity speakers, delivering a warm, detailed, and naturally flowing audio experience.